Скачать с ютуб #207 в хорошем качестве

#207

This week David and Marina discuss the best strategies for getting the most from a design review. The two cover when NOT to listen to critics, the two essential parts to any critique, why design reviews are often a complete mess, crying at reviews, controlling a review, bad feedback, how to structure a productive review, and much more. Enjoy! (00:00) Why are reviews important? Should students care about the feedback they receive? (09:35) The importance of displaying your work and showing up to the review. (13:44) Are reviews supposed to be easy? Taking feedback. (18:10) ‘Leveling the playing field’ of the review: Turning the review into a conversation. (22:10) Why design and architecture reviews can be incredibly unfair and what students can do about it. (25:45) Putting the critics (and their feedback) up on a pedestal and trying to please all of them. (32:20) Translating the critic’s feedback to helpful information. Why teachers should always have a post-review analysis. (39:26) Handling “negative” feedback and crying during reviews. (43:00) How to know if feedback is valid: The two parts of any feedback and whether or not the critics know design. (52:25) Should review feedback be more focused on the student or the building? (58:55) When critics have discussions that are interesting to them, but understandable to students. (01:01:20) Why using building references is a bad way to give feedback. Different types of critics to be aware of. (01:10:10) Two common critiques (01:15:55) Critics who push their own agenda. (01:19:45) Critics who get too excited during reviews (01:24:10) Tips for giving being a good critic. (01:33:19) Students who get undeserving praise. (01:34:15) Tips for structuring and hosting a review. (01:45:25) Why it’s beneficial to have one or two bad critics at a review. (01:47:28) Why do students have to learn how to manage a review. • SUBSCRIBE on YouTube: https://bit.ly/3p9VbF5 • APPLE PODCASTS: https://apple.co/2U6xFdR • SPOTIFY: https://spoti.fi/32q6b7M Connect: #secondstudiopod • WEBSITE: https://www.secondstudiopod.com/ • INSTAGRAM:   / secondstudiopod   • FACEBOOK:   / secondstudiopod   • TWITTER:   / secondstudiopod   • CALL/TEXT your suggestions and questions to 213-222-6950 About: The Second Studio (formerly The Midnight Charette) is an explicit podcast about design, architecture, and the everyday. Hosted by Architects David Lee and Marina Bourderonnet, it features different creative professionals in unscripted and long-format interviews with thoughtful takes and personal discussions. Honesty and humor are used to cover a wide array of subjects. Episode Types: • GUEST INTERVIEWS: Interviews with leading professionals • AFTER HOURS: Casual conversations • FELLOW DESIGNER: Tips for designers • DESIGN REVIEWS: Review of buildings and other projects